The caption
The parties exactly as the court lists them—not a claim about the merits.
State court of last resort · ST-VA-SC
Fruiterman v. Granata
No. 071894Supreme Court of Virginia
071894 Fruiterman v. Granata 10/31/2008 (Revised 04/06/2009) In separate wrongful birth cases filed by the mother and father of twin daughters afflicted with Down syndrome, the circuit court judgment sustainin…
Clerk language is kept verbatim. Vote Files does not infer who is winning.The movement
Orders, motions, and filings in the clerk's own words and sequence.
The proof
The official docket and available court documents attached to every update.
071894 Fruiterman v. Granata 10/31/2008 (Revised 04/06/2009) In separate wrongful birth cases filed by the mother and father of t…
- Court
- Supreme Court of Virginia
- First seen
- Oct 4, 2026
- Last entry
- Oct 31, 2008
No bill or executive-order citation is attached to this file.
Official docket
Case timeline
The clerk's wording is shown verbatim and linked to the court's own document page where available.
Docket entry
071894 Fruiterman v. Granata 10/31/2008 (Revised 04/06/2009) In separate wrongful birth cases filed by the mother and father of twin daughters afflicted with Down syndrome, the circuit court judgment sustaining a jury verdict in favor of the mother is reversed because the evidence was insufficient as a matter of law to prove the element of proximate causation. In the father's case, the circuit court granted a motion to strike the evidence because the father failed to prove the existence of a physician-patient relationship, and that judgment is affirmed.
Open court document ↗Documents and links